Revisiting 'What works for whom?' A qualitative framework for evaluating clinical effectiveness in child psychotherapy

Urwin, Cathy (2007) Revisiting 'What works for whom?' A qualitative framework for evaluating clinical effectiveness in child psychotherapy. Journal of Child Psychotherapy, 33 (2). pp. 134-160. ISSN 1469-9370 (electronic) 0075-417X (paper) Full text available

PDF (Urwin - Revisiting)
Urwin_-_Revisiting.pdf - Published Version

Download (707kB) | Preview


This paper describes a framework for evaluating the effectiveness of child psychotherapy used by child psychotherapists in an inner city Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service (CAMHS). The Hopes and Expectations for Treatment Approach (HETA) involves using the assessment for psychotherapy that normally precedes treatment to derive a baseline from which to generate a set of hopes/expectations as regards the effects of the treatment on the part of parents and the psychotherapist, to be revisited one year after the start of the psychotherapy and/or at its completion. The Strength and Difficulties Questionnaire, for parents and schools, was also administered before and after the treatment. The characteristics of the first 30 children referred for psychotherapy over a particular time period are described. Of the first 15 children in this group to complete one year of individual psychotherapy, all showed change or significant change in the areas concerning parents' and therapists' hopes at the end-of-year review, as rated by parents and psychotherapists. A case of a child with conduct disorder is used to describe how the assessment generated a psychoanalytic formulation, how the therapist's understanding was fed back to the parents, and how the parents' and therapist's hopes and expectations were derived and recorded. This case illustrates powerfully the impact of trauma in the parents' backgrounds on the internal world of the child, and how the method provides a useful bridge between parent and child work. Feedback from the psychotherapists, the parents and the referrers using the framework is reviewed, and in conclusion the paper argues for the framework's value in promoting good practice in the treatment and management of complex cases and in enhancing awareness of the nature and scope of the psychotherapy process.

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: Evaluation, Clinical Effectiveness, Conduct Disorder, Hopes and Expectations Approach (HETA), Psychotherapy Assessment, Child & Adolescent Psychoanalysis, Child & Adolescent Psychotherapy, Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy, Psychological Disorders
Subjects: Children, Young People and Developmental Pyschology > Child Psychotherapy
Department/People: Children, Young Adult and Family Services

Actions (Library Staff login required)

View Item View Item